Monday, November 16, 2026

Why people really object to AI datacentres

Opposition to "hyperscale" AI datacentres is rife and growing, in America, in Canada, across the world. Probably even in China if we were to ever find out about it. It seems pretty much everyone hates them.

I have always assumed that the "movement" - it's not really a movement, there is no manifesto, no central organization, not even a consistent impetus - was really all about nimbyism (not-in-my-back-yard-ism), but the more I read, the less that assumption seems to hold. 

When you read articles, such as the one in today's Globe and Mail, about opposition to datacentres in ultra-conservative rural Alberta, for example, you are reading about wealthy horse-riding ranchers objecting to an ugly behemoth rising in their idyllic rural enclave, accompanied by an even uglier gas-powered power station to power it. They don't like the way it looks, they don't like the idea of it increasing their electricity and water rates or decreasing their property values. This certainly seems to be nimbyism, and maybe in this case, it is. These are probably the same people who objected to solar and wind farms encroaching on their rural paradise. Hell, there are even Alberta farmers protesting against oil development these days!

But the sheer cross-party breadth of the opposition to datacentres suggest that there is more going on here. From ageing Trump lovers to youthful left-wing radicals, datacentres is an issue that has united the must unlikely of bed-mates. And, at core, this does seem to be a manifestation of widespread opposition to artificial intelligence as a whole, and the way in which it is being rolled out, with little or no public consultation and with little or no regulation. 

Many jurisdictions - and Alberta is a good example here - opened their doors to the AI ambitions of Big Tech, and the power- and water-hungry datacentres that come with it, because they see it as a money-earning boondoggle. It seems that public opposition to their plans has taken them completely by surprise, causing an increasing level of wariness among politicians, especially local authorities, and many of them are frantically back-pedalling. No less than 145 datacentres are planned throughout the province but, thus far, only one is actually in the process of being built, and that project is facing increasing hostility.

Opposition to datacentres is just about the only way regular folks can express their opposition to AI in general. The faceless titans like Meta, Google, Amazon, Anthropic and Nvidia are far removed from the everyday affairs of farmers and factory workers, and local opposition to a new datacentre is a tangible way people can express their concerns about how Big Tech is steamrollering its way ahead, earning the big bucks without any real oversight (and without recompensing local people).

Plus, the more people read about AI and its impact on everything from employment to privacy to the environment, and the more they experience first-hand some of the AI slop that is rapidly taking over the internet, the more they question whether it is actually an unalloyed good, and indeed whether we even need AI at all. If AI is really about to precipitate the end of the world, they are asking why we should be enabling it. Pretty reasonable, really.

Unfortunately, the genie is out of the bottle, and such belated disquietude is unlikely to have much influence on big decisions being made behind closed (and closely-guarded) doors. But people can still protest against new datacentres, without which AI can not continue to grow in strength and clout.

No comments: