An interesting piece in The Guardian shows how most people are positively disposed to wind and solar farms, even if those same people assume that others are not, and if most press coverage of these new technologies is predominantly negative.
This perception gap was highlighted by a recent British poll which found that 73% of the British public support wind power, and an even larger percentage (80%) support solar farms. This support can be broken down into 65% of people in rural areas (a constituency widely thought to be anti-wind development) and 75% in urban areas. The age demographic is also telling, with 77% of young people (aged 18 - 24) in favour of wind power compared to 66% of over-65s. Support in Scotland, the windiest part of the country, was even higher, with an 80% approval rate, which accords with other studies suggesting that people are more likely to favour wind farms if they have a financial stake in them, and also that people who live near wind farms overwhelmingly feel that the turbines have improved their area (also contrary to popular belief).
Contrast this, though, with the perception of other people's support for wind power: when asked to estimate what percentage of the population agreed with their own suppport of wind farms, only 10% thought that 71% or more of people would also support wind farms. And, while 80% of people said they supported solar farms, just 11% expected that many people to agree with them.
In trying to explain this disconnect, one possible explanation might be found in the disproportionately negative nature of media editorials and comment pieces on wind power. A study by 1010uk.org found that 52% of newspaper editorials were negative, 31% neutral, and only 17% positive. Over four times as many editorials were framed to look at the risks of the technology as were framed to look at the benefits (interestingly, editorial coverage of fracking showed the opposite relationship). This suggests that those who oppose wind power (and those who support fracking), for whatever reason, seem to be managing to find a disproportionate amount of space to air those views in the papers.
Make of all that what you will, but it does seem that then British Prime Minister David Cameron's 2014 cancellation of Britain's wind and renewables subsidies on the grounds that the public was "fed up" with wind farms was not actually based on good evidence, but rather was more likely to have been an attempt to placate the strong nuclear and fossil fuel lobbies. Didn't do him much good, though, did it?
Thursday, October 20, 2016
Justin Trudeau and the Liberals after the first year in power
As Justin Trudeau and his Liberal government complete one year in office after their resounding electoral victory last October, many media outlets are taking the opportunity to grade his progress and achievements so far, and to look ahead to his prospects of fulfilling his ambitious electoral mandate in the months to come.
After a very promising start, I must confess to some disappointment and frustration with the man and his party in recent months. But he has managed to achieve one thing that hardly any previous Prime Minister (including his own, generally well-regarded, father) has ever been able to boast: he is apparently more popular now than he was when elected. Although the Liberals won over 54% of the seats in Parliament in the election, their share of the popular vote was actually only about 39% (see my comments on electoral reform below). But his much-vaunted "sunny ways" and his star power seem to have won over many who were not totally convinced by him at the time of the election. Some blame a leaderless and directionless opposition for at least part of this effect, but it is nevertheless quite an achievement. It certainly makes a very pleasant change to have a leader who is liked and respected the world over, and Canadians abroad are finally starting to hold their heads up again after a decade of embarrassment.
There is no doubt that Mr. Trudeau came in with guns a-blazing. He promptly withdrew Canada's CF-18 fighter jets from the air war against IS in favour of training and ground support; he went ahead with the immigration and resettlement of 25,000 Syrian refugees in Canada, despite a series of world events that might easily have derailed the process; he ended Stephen Harper's visa requirements for Mexican visitors; he made moves to increase taxation on the richest Canadians and to lower taxes for the middle class; he reinstated the long-form census axed by Stephen Harper, to great popular approval; he instigated a long-overdue inquiry into missing and murdered aboriginal women; he installed a gender-balanced cabinet, and re-opened long-soured lines of communication with provincial premiers, native leaders, and the press; he tried to rescue what is left of Canada's environmental reputation and integrity by signing the Paris accord on climate change; he personally negotiated the release of a Canadian missionary long held in a Chinese jail and eased a simmering trade dispute over canola exports to China, while only hinting vaguely at future talks on an extradition treaty with China (it remains to be seen whether such talks actually come to anything, and that might yet colour his other achievements in China).
Yes, there have been a few set-backs along the way, some of which I have already commented on in this blog - "nannygate", "elbowgate", aides' relocation expenses, etc - but these have been relatively minor and usually deftly handled. The disappointing government response to the ongoing scandal of Canadian arms sales to Saudi Arabia is a more concerning development, and is bruising Mr. Trudeau's squeaky clean reputation both abroad and at home.
However, now that the low-hanging fruit has been plucked, there are several much more knotty problems to deal with in the coming months. For example, negotiating a health transfer deal with the provinces will be a challenge, as it always is. A climate change deal, including the imposition of a carbon tax on those provinces that do not already have one, will also be a challenge, although mainly due to the maverick Brad Wall in Saskatchewan (and kudos to Trudeau for having the cojones to propose it in the first place, and to finally talk seriously about bringing in energy conservation and renewable energy regulations for new building projects).
Trudeau also seems to be distancing himself from the Liberals' major election promise to change the electoral system in Canada from the current first-past-the-post (FPTP) model to some kind of proportional representation system. Despite an unambiguous promise that the last election would be the last to be held under the FPTP system, Mr. Trudeau is now hinting that any decision to reform the country's electoral system should lie with the people, and his feeling seems to be that, after electing a majority Liberal government to replace the unpopular Stephen Harper Conservatives, the people are actually quite happy with FPTP. This is rather circular and self-serving reasoning, and has more the sound of a cynical political pragmatist rather than that of a young naïve idealist.
Other cracks are also starting to appear in the shining armour of the Liberals, one example being the apparently widespread use of exclusive and expensive fundraisers which give those who are willing to pay exclusive access to senior cabinet minsters. Although, Trudeau vehemently denies it, such events appear to contravene the Liberals own stringent rules on lobbying and fundraising.
So, some good, some bad, some middling, and some judgements reserved. One the whole, though, a reasonably promising first year, I think it's fair to say, and certainly not a disaster.
Tuesday, October 18, 2016
Sweet potato breeding program is a win-win solution for sub-Saharan Africa
A simple but very effective expedient being developed in Uganda could save millions of children across Africa from malnutrition.
Sweet potatoes are one of the three main food crops in Uganda (along with plantain and cassava), as indeed they are they are in much of south and central Africa. But the starchy white-fleshed sweet potatoes that are usually grown in Uganda are relatively low in Vitamin A, and Vitamin A deficiency is a huge public health problem throughout sub-Saharan Africa, affecting as many as 43 million children across the continent (children affected by the condition are more likely to go blind, suffer from stunted growth, contract diseases, and to die earlier).
Earlier this month, though, Ugandan scientist Dr. Robert Mwanga received a quarter-share of the prestigious and lucrative World Food Prize - a prize worth $250,000 and awarded for "improving the quality, quantity or availability of food in the world" - for his work in combining local varieties of sweet potato with others from around the world, particularly the non-native orange-fleshed sweet potato (which is very high in Vitamin A), in order to build in more vitamin A and to produce a vitamin-rich breed tailored to suit local tastes and the local climate.
The new crop was developed without the need to resort to expensive and controversial genetic modification, like the ill-fated golden rice experiment in Asia. Rather, it relies on bio-fortification using only conventional breeding methods The resulting potato grows well, has high yields, and the local population has already seen its health benefits over the last few years. It is also a significantly cheaper and more practical solution to Vitamin A deficiency than the vitamin capsule supplement programs that have been attempted to date.
Win-win, I'd say.
First hijab-wearing Muslim to appear in Playboy
Noor Tagouri is a 22 year old American (born in Libya) Muslim journalist and motivational speaker who has ruffled some feathers in the Middle East by becoming the first hijab-wearing Muslim to pose for Playboy.
Yes, she's good-looking, but, more to the point, she's smart as a whip and extremely articulate. And remember, "posing" in Playboy is not what it used to be, since the venerable magazine stopped publishing pictures of fully nude women about a year ago.
As Noor tells it, though, what better place is there for her to tell her own story, and that of other Muslim Americans like her, than a media organ that has traditionally modelled itself around the objectification of women? After all, there is no point in preaching to the converted, is there?
Interestingly, she tells how she has had some push-back in the US too over her wearing of the hijab, and sometimes employers are reticent to take her on, and some interview subjects are unwilling to talk to her. Ms. Tagouri however, feels that some more marginalized subjects are actually more likely to trust her - another outsider - with their story.
Power to her!
Monday, October 17, 2016
Toronto cafe charges women more than men to highlight the "pink tax"
A Toronto coffee shop courted controversy recently when it started charging women more for their coffee than men.
Actually, it was a stunt organized by an American pressure group called GirlTalkHQ, which bills itself as "the global headquarters of female empowerment news media" (a rather awkward tagline, but you get the idea). The idea and the video it gave rise to are part of the organization's #FightPinkTax campaign to draw attention to the fact that women pay more for many product than men do for an essentially identical item, from clothing to toiletries to dry-cleaning to haircuts and beyond. By some estimates women pay up to $2,000 a year more than men due to this gender-based pricing.
The popular downtown Toronto cafe posted up new discriminatory prices on its pricing board, and the bar staff played along with the conceit, in order to get reactions from outraged customers. You can watch the results here.
GirlTalkHQ say they started this campaign in Canada because Canadians are already making some moves in the right direction on this issue. They give a special shoutout to Prime Minister (and soi-disant feminist) Justin Trudeau, who has made sex equality an important plank of his policy, and they make particular reference to his positive discrimination policy in his cabinet. You too can sign the petition which, it is hoped, will be handed to Mr. Trudeau and the Minister for the Status of Women with a formal appeal to end the imbalance.
Interestingly, though, some American jurisdictions are actually further ahead on this: the states of New York City and California have outlawed the practice of charging differently for products or services according to gender, and in California companies face fines up to $4,000 if they're caught breaking the law.
Sunday, October 16, 2016
Rwanda HFC/greenhouse gas deal a success worth celebrating
An important climate change deal recently signed at a UN conference in Rwanda has received relatively little media attention. Which is a shame, because it is potentially quite significant, and a good example of a little victory in a field where victories are hard to come by.
The 28th Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer took place in Kigali, Rwanda on 10–14 October 2016. While billed as an ozone meeting and not a climate change meeting, it will nevertheless have some important ramifications in the world's struggle to limit greenhouse gas emissions and to keep global warming within bounds.
During the meeting, 197 nations agreed to drastically reduce their use of hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs). HFCs were developed in the 1990s, after the 1989 Montreal Protocol in which it was agreed to phase out and replace the chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) that were widely in fridges and air conditioners. CFCs were found to be eating large holes in the earth's ozone layer, and the Montreal Protocol came to be seen as one of the world's great environmental success stories.
However, although HFCs effectively solved the ozone problem, it turned out that they were also a potent greenhouse gas, up to 10,000 times as effective as CO2 at trapping heat in the atmosphere as they leak out into the air. Because HFCs are now so widely used in refrigeration, and as newly industrializing countries like India and China expand their use of air conditioning, they represent a significant source of greenhouse gases worldwide (an estimated 8% of total global warming impact).
Now, HFCs can be reduced by making air conditioners and refrigerators more efficient, and by sealing up leak (so that HFCs do not seep into the atmosphere). But an alternative to HFCs is also now available, hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs), which are much more benign chemicals and trap much less heat in the atmosphere over their lifetimes.
Unfortunately, HFOs are significantly more expensive than HFCs or CFCs, and large but relatively poor developing countries like India and Brazil just cannot afford the switch without help. Under the Rwanda deal, therefore, the wealthier countries of North America and Europe will make the transition away from HFCs first, while developing countries will be allowed more time (and will hopefully benefit from reduced prices and increased efficiencies as new products and processes are developed). The wealthier countries will also help finance the transition of the less wealthy directly.
Because the agreement is an amendment under the existing Montreal Protocol, there are already reporting and enforcement mechanisms in place, and there are penalties for any countries that do not meet their commitments. The amendment is expected to reduce HFC use by up to 85% by 2047.
So, say it loud! Celebrate the successes! God knows, we see so few.
Friday, October 14, 2016
Think positive - Bob Dylan might still refuse his Nobel Prize
I'm very much in two minds about yesterday's announcement that Bob Dylan is the winner of this year's Nobel Prize in Literature, officially "for having created new poetic expressions within the great American song tradition". The permanent secretary of the Swedish Academy, Sara Danius, waxed lyrical in the official press release of the announcement, calling Dylan "a great poet in the great English tradition, stretching from Milton and Blake onwards", and even comparing him to Homer and Sappho at one point.
My first thought was: seriously? But the Nobel Prize committee is nothing if not serious. Occasionally controversial, sure (think Barack Obama, Yasser Arafat, Al Gore, etc), but never flippant or trivial.
So, I then assumed that the announcement must at least be a controversial one, at least in literature terms. But apparently not: the vast majority of comments I have read have been wildly positive, even delirious. Most people, then, seem perfectly at ease with the decision, calling it well-deserved, long overdue, even inspired.
All this has surprised me, to say the least. Am I the only person out there who thinks that Dylan is overrated? His lyrics, while admittedly well above the level of Lady Gaga or Ozzy Osbourne, are nevertheless just that, lyrics, and do not really hold up as poetry in their own right, at least not compared to the work of any number of bona fide poets. And don't get me started on his voice (I'm sure even he would admit he can't sing for toffee), although I assume that the Nobel committee do not take such non-literary aspects into account.
So, my suspicion is that the estimable committee, perhaps in a misguided attempt at appearing "relevant" or even "edgy", just decided that this year they would choose a singer-songwriter, someone well-known and commercially successful, a populist choice. Then, out of the canon of hoary mainstream old geezers of a certain age and with a sufficiently copious back catalogue (perhaps the likes of Joni Mitchell, Leonard Cohen, Patti Smith and others might have been considered), they decided to plump for a certain Robert Zimmerman.
I just kind of think that many of the top-notch authors who never won the Nobel Prize (a list, lest we forget, that includes the likes of Leo Tolstoy, Marcel Proust, James Joyce, Virginia Woolf, Jorge Luis Borges, Vladimir Nabokov, Primo Levi, W. H. Auden, John Updike, Robert Frost, Graham Greene, Chinua Achebe ... I could go on and on) might well be turning in their graves right now. And wasn't this supposed to be Philip Roth's year anyway? (Haruki Murukami was also widely touted.)
I think perhaps the best we can hope at this point is that the notoriously cantankerous Dylan might pull a Jean-Paul Sartre and refuse the accolade.
UPDATE
Nearly two weeks later, Mr. Dylan has still not bothered to contact the Swedish Academy or to publicly acknowledge the honour in any way. Apparently, a minor back-page of his official website did mention it briefly, but the mention soon disappeared, just as mysteriously.
The Nobel committee might just be starting to rue their decision right now...
UPDATE UPDATE
Nearly 5 months later, Dylan has finally, almost grudgingly, deigned to accept the prize, although behind closed doors, and with absolutely no press present. He will not deliver the customary (and required) lecture in person, but will send in a taped lecture, despite the fact that he will actually be there in Stockholm for a couple of concerts.
Now, whether you see him as an old cantankerous curmudgeon or a puffed up prima donna, even his fans must see this as a graceless and boorish way to carry on. Me, I just see him as a jerk, and hopefully this might have disabused the Nobel Committee of the wisdom of granting the prize to a so-called pop-star in the future.
Wednesday, October 12, 2016
Why are the Republicans turning on Donald Trump now?
With House of Representatives Speaker Paul Ryan the latest senior Republican to distance himself from Donald Trump, what interests and surprises me is not that the concerted Republican movement away from Trump has happened at all, but that it has taken so long, and what this says about the current state of the American right.
It took the release of the shock 2005 video about Mr. Trump's penchant for gratuitously groping women (including his favourite ploy, "grab them by the pussy", which has led to some people using the moniker "Pussygate") to galvanize Paul Ryan into officially decoupling himself from the Trump campaign, although it took him a couple of days to come to this conclusion, and in fact he has still not officially withdrawn his endorsement of Mr. Trump. This suggests, then, that Ryan was actually quite OK with a Republican leader threatening to throw his opponent in jail, or barring all Muslims for entering the United States, or building a wall to keep out Mexican rapists and drug smugglers, or any number of other Trump policies.
Granted, some other senior Republicans - people like Mitt Romney, John McCain, Lindsey Graham, etc - had already distanced themselves before the video revelations, and they deserve at least some credit for that. But the video seems to have been the tipping point for many (over 2 dozen have officially withdrawn their support just since Monday, and many more have at least made hedging statements), indicating that they have the moral outrage bar set pretty high. Currently, it is though that about a third of Republican senators have either said they are not supporting Trump, or else have called on him to drop out as Republican candidate. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and former presidential rivals Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio are all still on board the Trump train to nowhere, though, as is poor beleaguered running mate Mike Pence. (The Atlantic has produced a long a detailed list of party elders, representatives, senators, governors and influential opinion-makers, and their stance on The Donald.)
As Globe columnist John Ibbotson suggests, there is now a case for every Republican candidate in this election to have to stand up and officially declare to the world whether or not they still support Donald Trump and his policies. Better still, they should be asked whether or not they support him AND whether or not they plan on voting for him, because clearly the two things are not as closely linked as they might appear. They owe the voters that much at least.
As Globe columnist John Ibbotson suggests, there is now a case for every Republican candidate in this election to have to stand up and officially declare to the world whether or not they still support Donald Trump and his policies. Better still, they should be asked whether or not they support him AND whether or not they plan on voting for him, because clearly the two things are not as closely linked as they might appear. They owe the voters that much at least.
In a way, it is interesting that this should have been the straw that broke the camel's back for many people. It suggests that, for the right wing at any rate, overt sexism is a stronger taboo than overt and extreme racism, even though Trump has already made many degrading references to women during his campaign (including "bimbo", "dog", "fat pig", etc). Personally, I still harbour suspicions that the problem for many Republicans is not the disrespect that Trump shows for women, but an old-fashioned Christian objection to marital infidelity.
Rolling Stone opines, quite convincingly, that the reason that Republicans are scattering like rats from a sinking ship is just that: for a time, while the opinion polls remained optimistic, most Republicans were quite content to ride Trump's coattails to victory, regardless of their actual opinions of the man; but as soon as his support, especially in the critical battleground states, began to sink, Trump became an albatross from whom Republicans were desperate to cut free. For many, then, this is not so much an ethical decision, but a cynical exercise in Realpolitik.
Another rather disturbing part of what it all shows - in addition to the purely cynical aspect of what they are willing to do, what kind of deals with the devil they would strike, in order to gain power - is the extent to which Trump has singlehandedly shifted the American right wing rightwards. The fact that so many Republicans could apparently stomach some of the man's more extreme policies suggests a willingness on their part to return to the divisive, racist, sexist, politics of the 60's, to an extent that would have been unthinkable just four years ago.
Outside of the Republican establishment, though, things look even worse. Some of the behaviour that has come out at Trump rallies - T-shirts emblazoned with "Trump that bitch", "Lock her up" and the particularly succinct "Cunt" - would also have been unthinkable much more recently than four years ago. But, apparently, not today. And consider this: 8% of respondents in a recent poll said that the Trump "grab them by the pussy" video made them think BETTER of him, not worse; Republican lawmaker Michael Folk has publicly opined that Clinton should be "hung on the Mall", and Trump adviser Al Baldasaro has suggested that "she should be shot in a firing squad for treason"; 40% of Trump supporters in swing-state Ohio answered a recent poll that (in general terms not specific to this particular election) the country is better off with a male president than a female one. I could go on, but I'd only get even more depressed.
Ah God, but the man has a lot to answer for, however the election turns out.