Monday, January 19, 2026

What does MAGA really believe about DEI?

An article on Martin Luther King Day includes a quote from a Trump White House spokesperson: "Everything President Trump does is in the best interest of the American people. That includes rolling back harmful DEI agendas, deporting dangerous criminal illegal aliens from American communities, or ensuring we are being honest about our country's great history."

Now there are any number of things wrong with that quote, both in principle, and in the practical way in which those beliefs are being acted on. But the thing that really stood out for me was the use of the word "harmful". In what way is the pursuit of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) considered actually harmful by the MAGA crowd?

Here's what MAGA believes about DEI, gleaned mainly from an AI query and a CNN article:

  • DEI actively disadvantages White people and men, attempting to solve past discrimination by creating new forms of discirimination.
  • DEI leads to hiring or promoting less qualified minority candidates, shifting the focus from merit to identity.
  • DEI fosters resentment and focusses on differences, creating divisions, and turning people into victims and oppressors.
  • DEI is redundant in today's post-racial world, where significant racial equality has already been achieved.
  • DEI programs are costly, ineffective bureaucracies, filled with activists rather than genuine problem-solvers.
  • DEi policies violate constitutional rights, particularly for educators and students, promoting specific ideologies and stifling free speech.

Of course, a lot of these points are merely twists on the arguments for DEI. And I do believe that they are, by and large, "straw men" arguments (intentionally misrepresented propositions), and that a good proportion of the people espousing them just don't like Black people. But I have no proof of that :)

No comments:

Post a Comment